Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Feminized Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feminized Justice. Show all posts

Saturday, April 2, 2011

Feminized Justice: Update

Angela Fernandez of the University of Toronto has drawn my attention to her recent review of Feminized Justice, the book by Amanda Glasbeek I profiled here last week, on Jotwell, the Journal of Things We Like (Lots.) The "We" is legal scholars: the online journal is designed to fill "a telling gap in legal scholarship by creating a space where legal academics will go to identify, celebrate, and discuss the best new legal scholarship."

One of the rubrics of legal scholarship Jotwell celebrates is legal history. Angela is a regular contributing editor for this section (and the only Canadian.)

Her review begins by highlighting the bright pink background on the book jacket in contrast with the somber black and white male-dominated photograph:

This terrific book, coloured hot pink, has a black-and-whiite photograph of the Toronto Women’s Court on its cover.  The photograph is filled with a lot of men, at least a dozen, all wearing suits, and only two women.  Where were the women lawyers, women judges, women clerks and bailiffs, not to mention the female defendants who occasioned the gathering of all this officialdom?  The court had a male judge for its first eight years.  The small number of women in the photograph and the initial lack of a female judge points to the same kind of contradiction Amanda Glasbeek’s book is most concerned to highlight, namely, the way that this movement to create a female-friendly space for the “right” kind of woman (young ones who had temporarily lost their moral compass and needed to be protected) ended up mostly coercing, disciplining, and punishing a very different kind of woman (e.g. older veterans with persistent drinking problems who were deemed effectively non-reformable).
I won't reproduce the rest of the review (you can follow the link to read it yourself), but here's an enlarged image of the cover again so you can see what she is talking about.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

(Fairly Recent) Book of the Week

Although we are publishing this blog with the imprimatur of the Osgoode Society, we are well aware that Canadian Legal History does not begin and end with the Society. There are many excellent publishers and promoters of legal history out there, and one of them is the Law & Society series of the University of British Columbia Press, under the general supervision of legal historian Wes Pue.

One of the series' books from 2009 which deserves wide readership is Feminized Justice: The Toronto Women's Court, 1913-34  by York University socio-legal scholar, Canadian Law and Society Association board member and website manager (English) and all-round nice person Amanda Glasbeek.

Here's the publisher's blurb:
In 1913, Toronto launched an experiment in feminist ideals: a woman’s police court. The court offered a separate venue to hear cases that involved women and became a forum where criminalized women and feminists met and struggled with the meaning of justice.

The court was run by and for women, but was it a great achievement? Amanda Glasbeek’s multifaceted portrait of the cases, defendants, and officials that graced its halls reveals a fundamental contradiction at the experiment’s core: the Toronto Women’s Police Court was both a site for feminist adaptations of justice and a court empowered to punish women.

Reconstructed from case files and newspaper accounts, this engrossing portrait of the trials and tribulations that accompanied an early experiment in feminized justice sheds new light on maternal feminist politics, women and crime, and the role of resistance, agency, and experience in the criminal justice system.